Finding the Truth: The Death Cap Mushroom Case

It’s a court case that captured the attention of the world. Australian woman, Erin Patterson, was accused of killing three family members and attempting to kill another, on 29 July 2023, by serving them death cap mushrooms in a beef wellington meal. Now, two years later, Erin Patterson was brought to trial. The trial lasted nine weeks. “In his final instructions to the jury, the judge told them that where there were discrepancies in witness statements, it was up to them to decide what, if anything, was true.” [ABC news broadcast]

On 7 July, 2025, after deliberating for seven days, the jury returned a guilty verdict. Everyone, including the large number of journalists who have been watching, agreed that it had been a difficult time for everyone. Finding the truth isn’t easy.

It seems that the evidence was a tangled mess, with many lies being told. Colin Mandy SC, Erin’s defence, said, “‘She’s not on trial for lying. This is not a court of moral judgment.’

He accused the prosecution of trying to force a jigsaw puzzle of evidence together, ‘stretching interpretations, ignoring alternative explanations because they don’t align perfectly with the narrative’.

But the prosecution argued Erin had told so many lies it was hard to keep track of them.

‘She has told lies upon lies because she knew the truth would implicate her,’ Dr Rogers said. ‘When she knew her lies had been uncovered, she came up with a carefully constructed narrative to fit with the evidence – almost.’”  BBC news

Jurors have to find the truth

“In the end, it was the jurors listening to the evidence who had to sift through the stories, and all the different accounts, of Erin Patterson. To weigh up the evidence and consider the importance of an estranged wife venting online, an accused murderer insisting on her innocence and the conflicting accounts offered by Erin and other witnesses. The trial is now over with convictions of murder and attempted murder handed down. Erin Patterson has become a name steeped in infamy,” ABC news mushroom murder trial

In my previous blog,  Are They Telling the Truth?   I have noted that the idea of absolute truth is not as widely held as it once was. Some would say that truth is just what we want it to be, and my truth is no better than yours. However, in the mushroom murder case, as in all court cases, everyone expects that the jury will find the truth. Truth will be revealed. The real truth.

The truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth

We expect our justice system to be impartial and unbiased. Lady Justice, shown in the picture, is blindfolded. She is impartial to emotion, wealth, power, or status. But she can see the truth. She weighs the evidence in her scales. She carries a sword, symbol of authority, with the idea that justice can be swift and final.

Witnesses make an oath or an affirmation – a verbal, solemn and formal promise/declaration to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth. Court oaths and affirmations.

Presumption of innocence

So, if everyone has sworn to tell the truth, why don’t they? Just admit the truth and face the facts – you did wrong, and will have to face the consequences.

Mmm. It’s not that easy. In Australia, we have the presumption of innocence. By law, we are protected from having to incriminate ourselves. It’s up to the prosecution to prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt.

“People lie, people give false evidence, and people do all things in between. They may do this in the course of attempting to prove guilt or innocence. This is a fact of human nature and why a person charged with an offence is presumed innocent, not a saint.

The presumption of innocence presumes the best of us and not the worst. It places humans on a high plane and thereby facilitates, where appropriate, a plea of guilty.  This is important in the administration of justice and us feeling right with the system of justice.

People living in Australia today are free. Most of the people in the world are not. This is a fact and is due to our observance of the presumption of innocence.” Rule of law – presumption of innocence

As noted in a previous blog, What is Truth? Australian journalist, Peter Greste, was accused, arrested and sentenced  without the presumption of innocence.

Beyond reasonable doubt

Our justice system also requires jurors to be convinced, “beyond reasonable doubt”, before they find the accused person guilty.

“The defence argued that the deaths were tragic accidents. Before deliberations, defence barrister Colin Mandy SC urged the jury to consider whether there was a reasonable possibility that the death cap mushrooms were accidentally included in the meal.” ABC news 

The divine rightness of law

Lady Justice is described as the “embodiment of divine order, law, and custom, in her aspect as the personification of the divine rightness of law.” Lady Justice

It really is difficult to sort the truth from the lies. I’m thankful I wasn’t on the jury.

I am grateful for our human justice system with its presumption of innocence.

God knows all my sins too. God is just. His system of justice is perfect.

Righteousness and justice are the foundation of your throne; love and faithfulness go before you.

Psalms 89:14

You are righteous, Lord, and your laws are right. 

Psalms 119:137

He is the Rock, his works are perfect, and all his ways are just. A faithful God who does no wrong, upright and just is he.

Deuteronomy 32:4

God says that for all of us, there will be a time of final judgement, at a time determined by Him.

I choose the appointed time; it is I who judge with equity.

Psalms 75:2

For we must all appear before the judgment seat of Christ, so that each of us may receive what is due us for the things done while in the body, whether good or bad.

2 Corinthians 5:10

We will all face judgement

Now that’s a scary thought! I’m going to be judged by God. He doesn’t need a jury to weigh up the evidence. He already knows it all. He knows all my sinful deeds, and words, and even my thoughts! I can’t hide anything from God.

Erin Patterson will have to face the consequences of her actions. I will have to face the consequences of my sin too. 

Payment must be made for my crimes. That’s true justice. I can’t ever pay. On my own, I am a lost and condemned person. I deserve to go to eternal punishment in hell.

But, thank the Lord, Jesus paid for me. He took my punishment.

God made him who had no sin to be sin for us, so that in him we might become the righteousness of God.

2 Corinthians 5:21

Amazing grace

I can’t understand it. I am guilty. Yet, Jesus chose to take my penalty. He chose to die for me.

So that I can come into the presence of Holy God. So that I can live forever in heaven.

I am overwhelmed with emotion when I consider what it cost Jesus. It cost Him everything. Yet I get the gift for free. I can’t do anything to earn it.

God is just and holy. All sin must be paid for. Jesus paid for it all.

Not because I earned it or deserved it. Because He loves us. God is loving and merciful.

Jesus paid for your sins too. He didn’t wait for your permission. He didn’t wait to see if you’d deserve it. The free gift of salvation is for you too!

When you were dead in your sins and in the uncircumcision of your flesh, God made you alive with Christ. He forgave us all our sins, having cancelled the charge of our legal indebtedness, which stood against us and condemned us; he has taken it away, nailing it to the cross.

Colossians 2:13-14

Here is a true word of God. You can say it with your own name at the start:

[Name], the blood of Jesus his Son cleanses you from all sin.  1 John 1:7b 

Now, say it with ‘me’ instead of ‘you.’ 

The blood of Jesus cleanses me from all sin!

Hallelujah!

Next Time:

I plan to explore more about truth in my next blog, Does Truth Matter?.

If you subscribe to www.jesusontheroad.com you will be notified as soon as a new blog is posted.

Click on the button below to subscribe.